The morning was one of the most painful mornings for me.
I had messages on text informing me of a terror attack in Paris. Since I have a weird connection with Paris, (where if anyone I know is in Paris, there is usually some other person totally disconnected to the first person also present there at the same time.) I first thought of any of the people in my circles, if anyone had updated, checked-in or told me about being in Paris. One friend and her husband came to mind instantly, who were safe.
Reading and following the news and my friends', relatives', students' status updates on social media did make me feel a bit sad and angry. I'll tell you why.
I came across countless people sharing stuff like "yes, it is sad this happened in Paris, but what about Beirut, Syria.. why didn't we change our profile pictures, or share statuses about that?" I am sure you must have come across these types of updates too.
I think this is firstly a disservice to the dead and the injured in Paris and their loved ones. These people, people from all over the world, are grieving and some are still searching for their loved ones because a lot of dead bodies are yet to be identified, such was the evil destruction that had fallen on Paris.
In trying to communicate "brown lives matter", we are actually lessening the value of "white lives", which is unfair. And this is coming from me, a very much brown guy.
Think how would the loved one feel when he/she opens up the social media and sees these arguments. "What about Beirut?"
I am one of those types who changes his statuses and profile pictures (at least on Whatsapp where I actually can reach more people than Facebook, yeah I have counted.) The shock of Paris, along with it's similarity to the Mumbai terrorist attacks of 2008, made me immediately change my status to the French Flag. Later I changed it to French, Lebanese, Syrian and Russian Flags, all together. The people in the middle east have suffered the most, especially the most vulnerable like the Yazidis.
The second argument people were sharing was that it was obvious that France would have a blowback to it's efforts aimed against ISIS. So you are telling me that trying to stop Yazidis being slaughtered, raped and sold into slavery is going to get a reaction? I would actually would have appreciated the argument like "Of course ISIS would expect a blowback, how dare they do these
Thirdly, people are saying that of course the immigrants in Western nations would go and join ISIS because they are alienated, oppressed etc. by the Western nations, within Western nations. Okay, so how does that justify atrocities against the Yazidis? I am yet to get an answer on that.
You have understand the situation subjectively here. Imagine a city that is flooding due to storms and heavy rains. The ground floor is closest to the ground, it will have water inside, that is assumed. But if water starts getting into the fourth floor, that would be a big shock. We would sympathize with both of the households, but for the fourth floor we would be, "What the F!?!" This is what has happened. In case, you didn't get it, ground floor is Beirut, Lebanon (Shia, Hezbollah, border with Syria and Iraq), while the fourth floor is France, separated by thousands of kilometers EU states, then Turkey. I hope I am not offending the suffering peoples, but I hope they will understand my anguish at the lack of sensitivity shown to the other suffering.
Let's get one thing straight.
We, the people of this Earth have to unite and fight terrorism and extremism wherever it is, by being united. Just shrugging off French, (i.e.White/European) and global lives (especially Indian, African) with "What about Beirut?" kind of arguments is not going to do that. It's not going to be the balm that the French need. And they need it.
I would just say this to those who are sharing certain stuff, to think again.
It's time we change our tones. The message of equality would be so much better in a compassionate one. Imagine going to your friend's dad's funeral (God forbid) and telling him, "hey he died, but your family is rich and upper class, what about the poor who die of malnutrition?" Would we say that? Even think of saying something like that? No right? We would control ourselves and say, " I am sorry for your loss my friend, may your dad's soul rest in peace", wouldn't we? So shut up right now, be political correct at the right thing for once. A genuine "We are sorry" would do right now.
(image courtesy: intoday.in)
The Egyptians were on point(pic below). May God bless us all (also whatever works for my atheist readers).
(image courtesy: telegraph.co.uk)
I had messages on text informing me of a terror attack in Paris. Since I have a weird connection with Paris, (where if anyone I know is in Paris, there is usually some other person totally disconnected to the first person also present there at the same time.) I first thought of any of the people in my circles, if anyone had updated, checked-in or told me about being in Paris. One friend and her husband came to mind instantly, who were safe.
Reading and following the news and my friends', relatives', students' status updates on social media did make me feel a bit sad and angry. I'll tell you why.
I came across countless people sharing stuff like "yes, it is sad this happened in Paris, but what about Beirut, Syria.. why didn't we change our profile pictures, or share statuses about that?" I am sure you must have come across these types of updates too.
I think this is firstly a disservice to the dead and the injured in Paris and their loved ones. These people, people from all over the world, are grieving and some are still searching for their loved ones because a lot of dead bodies are yet to be identified, such was the evil destruction that had fallen on Paris.
In trying to communicate "brown lives matter", we are actually lessening the value of "white lives", which is unfair. And this is coming from me, a very much brown guy.
Think how would the loved one feel when he/she opens up the social media and sees these arguments. "What about Beirut?"
I am one of those types who changes his statuses and profile pictures (at least on Whatsapp where I actually can reach more people than Facebook, yeah I have counted.) The shock of Paris, along with it's similarity to the Mumbai terrorist attacks of 2008, made me immediately change my status to the French Flag. Later I changed it to French, Lebanese, Syrian and Russian Flags, all together. The people in the middle east have suffered the most, especially the most vulnerable like the Yazidis.
The second argument people were sharing was that it was obvious that France would have a blowback to it's efforts aimed against ISIS. So you are telling me that trying to stop Yazidis being slaughtered, raped and sold into slavery is going to get a reaction? I would actually would have appreciated the argument like "Of course ISIS would expect a blowback, how dare they do these
Thirdly, people are saying that of course the immigrants in Western nations would go and join ISIS because they are alienated, oppressed etc. by the Western nations, within Western nations. Okay, so how does that justify atrocities against the Yazidis? I am yet to get an answer on that.
You have understand the situation subjectively here. Imagine a city that is flooding due to storms and heavy rains. The ground floor is closest to the ground, it will have water inside, that is assumed. But if water starts getting into the fourth floor, that would be a big shock. We would sympathize with both of the households, but for the fourth floor we would be, "What the F!?!" This is what has happened. In case, you didn't get it, ground floor is Beirut, Lebanon (Shia, Hezbollah, border with Syria and Iraq), while the fourth floor is France, separated by thousands of kilometers EU states, then Turkey. I hope I am not offending the suffering peoples, but I hope they will understand my anguish at the lack of sensitivity shown to the other suffering.
Let's get one thing straight.
We, the people of this Earth have to unite and fight terrorism and extremism wherever it is, by being united. Just shrugging off French, (i.e.White/European) and global lives (especially Indian, African) with "What about Beirut?" kind of arguments is not going to do that. It's not going to be the balm that the French need. And they need it.
I would just say this to those who are sharing certain stuff, to think again.
It's time we change our tones. The message of equality would be so much better in a compassionate one. Imagine going to your friend's dad's funeral (God forbid) and telling him, "hey he died, but your family is rich and upper class, what about the poor who die of malnutrition?" Would we say that? Even think of saying something like that? No right? We would control ourselves and say, " I am sorry for your loss my friend, may your dad's soul rest in peace", wouldn't we? So shut up right now, be political correct at the right thing for once. A genuine "We are sorry" would do right now.
(image courtesy: intoday.in)
The Egyptians were on point(pic below). May God bless us all (also whatever works for my atheist readers).
(image courtesy: telegraph.co.uk)